Compare runs Export
Figures Sensitivity Report
Recordings / M13Rec001 / Signature

M13Rec001, Mouse heart, spiral wave and optogenetic termination

64 × 55 px, 9,267 frames, 1 kHz, 133 µm/px, deposit checks: negative values, nan mask all frames, temporal smoothing, spatial smoothing

Run 339921d8, 2026-10-28 18:40 UTC, protocol parameters v3, code 008c2dc (uncommitted changes), 9 workers, signature 9b40a32d, run view 339921d8, 13 signatures of this recording

Not reportable: range check not passed, code uncommitted changes, parameters unsigned, reviewer sign-off pending; 20 rules open

Parameters

% Mouse whole heart optical mapping (Luther lab), v3, read-only
% set by developer (not a domain scientist); provisional, REVIEW_NEEDED 16
baseline_frames  = 901;     % >= 2 x slowest cycle (415, MAP): ok
pad_frames       = 500;     % each side, outside the window
spatial_sigma    = 1.0;     % px, Gaussian, phase only
spatial_truncate = 4.0;     % kernel radius, sigma
lowpass          = [];      % none
polarity         = -1;      % measured, skew of dV/dt
rotor_threshold  = 0.9;     % turns, |winding| per plaquette
rotor_erode_px   = 3;       % px from tissue edge ignored
link_px          = 4.0;     % tracking, max step per frame
max_gap          = 5;       % frames a track may vanish
min_cycles       = 1.0;     % own rotations, min_frames = 52
pair_dist_px     = 3.0;     % opposite-charge pairing
paired_frac      = 0.5;     % max paired fraction of a track
render_step      = 4;       % movie only

Segments

SegmentDefinedAnalysedCycle, framesExpected RotorsBounded By
Illumination with arrhythmia0–3,170500–3,17052 (n = 53)presentLED on before frame 0 (DAQ) → termination step (image, ±17 frames)
Illumination after termination3,170–4,9773,170–4,977415 (n = 4)absenttermination step (image, ±17 frames) → illumination off (DAQ, ±11 frames)
Light off4,977–9,2674,977–8,767411 (n = 10)absentillumination off (DAQ, ±11 frames) → recording end

Frames at 9,267 total, 1.0 ms per frame. Cycle from the MAP channel of the DAQ log (median interval) when one exists, else from per-pixel dominant frequency. Boundaries, expectations and the segment design are provisional (project lead (not a domain scientist), following the paper's design, 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1011660).

Metrics

MetricUnitIllumination with arrhythmiaIllumination after terminationLight offPhysiological Range
Rhythm
Dominant frequencyHz 15.356–19.8502.2142.375 18.75–20 Hz, one recording, 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1011660, ±25% provisional
Rotors
Persistent rotorscount 4–1500 none cited
Max concurrent persistent rotorscount 1–200 none cited
Frames with a singularityfraction 0.4790.001–0.0150.003–0.030 none cited
Beats, where a global rhythm exists
Beatscount 5749 none cited
Global amplitude ratioratio 0.720.950.95 gate ≥ 0.30 provisional
APD50ms 141616 none cited
APD90ms 257675 none cited
Conduction velocitycm/s 31.358.560.0 none cited

Values at the run setting. Red: range across the sensitivity grid (12 baseline × sigma settings, 3 trackers) where the spread exceeds 25 % of the median; not reportable as a value. Beat metrics are not varied over the grid. Dominant frequency over the whole analysed window: 2.419 Hz.

CriterionRuleResult
Singularities present where the design expects them, absent elsewhereeach 'present' segment: frac >= 0.1 and >= 2.0 x max frac over 'absent' segments, at every settingholds at 12 filter settings provisional
Persistent rotors present where the design expects them, absent elsewhereeach 'present' segment: count >= 1; each 'absent' segment: count <= 0, at every settingholds at 12 filter settings and 3 trackers provisional
Persistence threshold, paper contextlifetime ≥ 52 frames (measured cycle) and ≥ 50 frames (cited 20 Hz)agree provisional

Report

The PDF carries the parameters as run, segments, metrics, criteria, reportable values, every provisional rule, the review items, the opening frame as camera, voltage and phase with the parameter footer, and the provenance block. The JSON carries the same plus the full stored metrics, sensitivity and critic records.

Methods

For recording 55cb4aa3-6502-45a6-a14c-85cb676fe8c3 under protocol f65d786f-f194-4be2-88b8-10d3dd25d674, the provisional parameter set version 3 is used with baseline_frames=901, spatial_sigma=1.0, spatial_truncate=4.0, pad_frames=500, rotor_threshold=0.9, rotor_erode_px=3, link_px=4.0, max_gap=5, min_cycles=1.0, pair_dist_px=3.0, paired_frac=0.5, and render_step=4. The frame rate is 1000 Hz from the publication, with DAQ consistency noted, and the pixel size is 133 µm from the publication. The recording has 9267 frames in a 64 by 55 npy movie; the analysed window is frames 500 to 8767. The provisional segment definitions are illuminated_arrhythmia from frames 0 to 3170, illuminated_after_termination from frames 3170 to 4977, and light_off from frames 4977 to 9267; the parameter set, the segment definitions and the criteria are provisional.

Reportable values

MetricSegmentValueUnitStatus
persistent rotor tracksall4–15countunstable, not reportable
dominant freq (Hz)light off2.375Hzno cited range
persistent rotorslight off0countno cited range
singularity frames fractionlight off0.0029–0.0296fraction of framesunstable, not reportable
persistent rotor count maxlight off0countno cited range
dominant freq (Hz)illuminated arrhythmia15.4–19.9Hzunstable, not reportable
persistent rotorsilluminated arrhythmia4–15countunstable, not reportable
dominant freq (Hz)illuminated after termination2.214Hzno cited range
singularity frames fractionilluminated arrhythmia0.479fraction of framesno cited range
persistent rotorsilluminated after termination0countno cited range
persistent rotor count maxilluminated arrhythmia1–2countunstable, not reportable
singularity frames fractionilluminated after termination0.000553–0.0149fraction of framesunstable, not reportable
persistent rotor count maxilluminated after termination0countno cited range

physiology_ok: not decided (no cited range passed or failed); send back: False. Verdict: report only sensitivity-stable qualitative/algorithmic findings and do not report unstable metrics as single values; physiology_ok is null because the only cited range check, illuminated_arrhythmia.dominant_freq_hz, is unstable rather than physiology-validated. Stable observations include 0 persistent rotors and 0 maximum persistent-rotor count in light_off and illuminated_after_termination, dominant frequencies of 2.375 Hz in light_off and 2.214 Hz in illuminated_after_termination, and illuminated_arrhythmia singularity_frames_frac over 0.3816479400749064–0.48801498127340825, all without cited physiological ranges; unstable, not reportable as single values, are light_off.singularity_frames_frac over 0.0029023746701846965–0.02955145118733509, illuminated_arrhythmia.persistent_rotors over 4.0–15.0, illuminated_arrhythmia.persistent_rotor_count_max over 1.0–2.0, illuminated_arrhythmia.dominant_freq_hz over 15.356–19.85 Hz, illuminated_after_termination.singularity_frames_frac over 0.0005534034311012728–0.014941892639734366, and persistent_rotor_tracks over 4.0–15.0. The persistent-rotor rule holds using both the 52-frame measured-cycle threshold and the 50-frame cited 20 Hz rotation-period threshold, which agree; the relevant same-study context reports approximately 20 Hz before illumination and approximately 18.75 Hz during illumination (DOI 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1011660). Review required: pre-deposit processing/raw-data label, frame-3170 event interpretation, baseline/illumination artifact, provisional tool thresholds, and tracker sensitivity; the ranges, the stability threshold and the criteria are provisional.

Provisional rules

Rule, LocationDescriptionExpertStatus
protocol_parameter_set
worker/voltage/protocol_params.py (developer_defaults, set_params)
Each protocol's fixed, versioned analysis parameters (version 1 = developer defaults); no run or agent may deviateoptical mapping analystprovisional
baseline_window_rule
worker/voltage/baseline_rule.py (FACTOR, evaluate)
A run proceeds only if the protocol's baseline window is >= 2x the slowest segment's cycle, the cycle from the MAP channel when a DAQ log exists, else from per-pixel dominant frequency on linearly detrended pixels; otherwise the run is held by codeoptical mapping analystprovisional
filter_defaults
worker/voltage/preprocess.py (Params)
Default baseline window (frames) and spatial Gaussian sigma/truncate for phaseoptical mapping analyst (cardiac electrophysiology)provisional
tissue_mask
worker/voltage/io.py (tissue_mask)
Tissue = not NaN in frame 0 and nonzero temporal stdoptical mapping analystprovisional
polarity
worker/voltage/preprocess.py (polarity)
Dye polarity from sign of median per-pixel skew of dV/dtoptical mapping analyst / voltage dye chemistprovisional
singularity_detection
worker/voltage/preprocess.py (Params.rotor_threshold, rotor_erode_px)
Phase singularity = |winding| > threshold turns, >= erode px from tissue edgecomputational cardiac electrophysiologist (phase mapping)provisional
rotor_persistence
worker/voltage/rotors.py (TrackParams)
Track linking distance/gap and minimum lifetime for a persistent rotorcomputational cardiac electrophysiologist (phase mapping)provisional
chirality_pairing
worker/voltage/rotors.py (TrackParams.pair_dist_px, paired_frac)
Opposite-charge singularities within pair distance are a pair; tracks paired most of their life are excluded from rotorscomputational cardiac electrophysiologist (phase mapping)provisional
sensitivity_grid
worker/voltage/sensitivity.py (SIGMAS, BASELINE_MULTIPLES, baseline_levels)
Filter levels tested: spatial sigma and baseline window valuesoptical mapping analystprovisional
analysis_window
worker/voltage/runs.py (default_window)
Frames analysed: whole recording minus one filter pad at each end (unless the plan narrows it)cardiac electrophysiologist familiar with the datasetprovisional
prior_processing_flags
worker/voltage/inspect.py (prior_processing)
Thresholds for flagging depositor processing (normalization, masking, temporal/spatial smoothing)imaging scientist (camera acquisition and noise)provisional
baseline_step_detection
worker/voltage/events.py (detect_baseline_step)
Baseline step = consensus upward step in tissue-mean raw baseline (cause not inferred; first misread as light onset, contradicted by the DAQ)optical mapping experimentalistprovisional
daq_interpretation
worker/voltage/daq.py
DAQ channel names from depositor notebook; frames = first N triggers of closest burst; midpoint thresholdsexperimentalist who recorded the data (or the depositor)provisional
segment_definitions
worker/voltage/annotations.py (MOUSE_SEGMENTS)
Mouse segments bounded by DAQ light events and the baseline step, interpreted as spiral termination under illumination (project lead, from Hussaini et al. 2023)cardiac electrophysiologist (ideally the depositing authors)provisional
rotor_finding_criterion
worker/voltage/sensitivity.py (MIN_FRAC, MIN_RATIO)
Singularity before/after finding holds if frac(before) >= min_frac and >= min_ratio x frac(after) at every setting (also kept, superseded, for persistent rotors)cardiac electrophysiologist + biostatisticianprovisional
persistent_rotor_criterion
worker/voltage/sensitivity.py (MIN_ROTORS_PRESENT, MAX_ROTORS_ABSENT)
Persistent-rotor finding holds if every 'present' segment has >= 1 persistent rotor and every 'absent' segment has none, at every settingcardiac electrophysiologistprovisional
pipeline_check
worker/agents/pipeline.py (INSTRUCTIONS, validator)
The pipeline agent's hold/proceed decision from protocol mismatches and inspector anomalies; it chooses no parameteroptical mapping analystprovisional
physiology_reference_rates
worker/voltage/physiology.py (RANGES, TOLERANCE_FRAC)
Cited physiological ranges (single-study values widened by a 25% tolerance), applied to segments by their expected rhythm; used by the critic and for frame-rate sanity checkscardiac electrophysiologist per speciesprovisional
stability_rule
worker/agents/critic.py (STABLE_FRAC, stability)
A metric is reportable only if its spread across all sensitivity settings is <= 25% of its median (zero spread when all values are 0); otherwise 'unstable, not reportable'biostatistician + optical mapping analystprovisional
persistence_threshold_variants
worker/agents/critic.py (persistence_variants)
The persistent-rotor rule is run at two lifetimes, one measured cycle of the fastest segment and the paper's cited rotation period; both verdicts stored, disagreement flaggedcomputational cardiac electrophysiologist (phase mapping)provisional

Review items

TopicDetailSeverityReviewer
unstable:light_off.singularity_frames_fracThis metric varies over 0.0029023746701846965–0.02955145118733509 across the filter grid and should not be reported as a single value.warndomain scientist / analysis lead
unstable:illuminated_arrhythmia.persistent_rotorsThis metric varies over 4.0–15.0 across filter and tracker settings and should not be reported as a single count.warndomain scientist / analysis lead
unstable:illuminated_arrhythmia.persistent_rotor_count_maxThis metric varies over 1.0–2.0 across filter and tracker settings and should not be reported as a single maximum concurrent count.warndomain scientist / analysis lead
unstable:illuminated_arrhythmia.dominant_freq_hzThis metric varies over 15.356–19.85 Hz across baseline-window settings; frequency interpretation should be reviewed against the same-study cited rotation context.warndomain scientist / electrophysiology reviewer
unstable:illuminated_after_termination.singularity_frames_fracThis metric varies over 0.0005534034311012728–0.014941892639734366 across the filter grid and should not be reported as a single value.warndomain scientist / analysis lead
unstable:persistent_rotor_tracksThis metric varies over 4.0–15.0 across filter and tracker settings and should not be reported as a single total track count.warndomain scientist / analysis lead
Pre-deposit processing / raw-data labelThe recording is labeled as raw experimental data, but documentation and measurements indicate masking, spatial smoothing, temporal smoothing, and normalization; do not treat it as raw camera photon counts for analyses that require raw data or independent pixel noise.warndata provenance reviewer
Event interpretation at frame 3170Frame 3170 is a baseline_step only; illumination began before frame 0 and ended at frame 4977, so the stored spiral-termination interpretation is provisional and should not be treated as direct light onset evidence.warndomain scientist
Baseline and illumination artifactThe publication reports stimulation-light crosstalk and re-normalization; the recording also has a large slow baseline range and a baseline step, so absolute baseline or amplitude analyses need artifact review.warnoptical mapping reviewer
Provisional tool thresholdsEvent detection, processing flags, SNR, rhythm, reference-rate thresholds, stability threshold, and criteria are provisional and should be checked for critical uses.infodomain scientist / methods reviewer
tracker sensitivity of rotor countsThe persistent-rotor rule agrees across strict, default, and loose trackers, but the illuminated-arrhythmia counts differ across trackers, so report the qualitative rule result rather than a single count.warnanalysis lead

Data and code availability

Recording10.5281/zenodo.10228296, CC-BY-4.0, Hussaini, Sayedeh; Luther, Stefan; Lädke, Sarah L.
Publication10.1371/journal.pcbi.1011660
Analysis code008c2dc076bcebf9e7fa01a05e8b7c4b5a713b37 (uncommitted changes)
Stored arraysruns/339921d8-9255-4d78-9789-6816dd8b409c/frames/voltage.npy, runs/339921d8-9255-4d78-9789-6816dd8b409c/frames/phase.npy, runs/339921d8-9255-4d78-9789-6816dd8b409c/frames/maps.npz
Rundone
Review items32 open